A troubling incident unfolded at Whitby Town Hall on March 23, 2026, when Rebel News reporter David Menzies was accused of harassing Whitby councillors and town staff following a committee-of-the-whole meeting. The altercation was serious enough that Durham Regional Police had to be called to the scene.
Whitby Mayor Elizabeth Roy described the encounter as crossing a clear line, stating that Menzies’ actions had made both councillors and staff feel “extremely uncomfortable.” She went on to condemn his behaviour, which she characterized as confrontational and intimidating, particularly toward female politicians.
“This individual has a well-documented history of confrontational interactions with public officials, including behaviour that many – particularly female politicians – have found to be intimidating,” said Mayor Roy. She made it clear that such conduct would not be tolerated at Whitby Town Hall and that she would ensure a safe environment for all council members and staff.
Menzies has been arrested multiple times in the past for alleged harassment of public officials, raising concerns about his repeated confrontations. The incident at Whitby Town Hall further escalated when town security had to intervene, advising Menzies that his behaviour was unacceptable. After repeated warnings, Durham police were called to de-escalate the situation and ensure safety.
In her statement, Mayor Roy clarified that the issue was not about limiting media access. Whitby Town Hall has welcomed numerous media outlets, both local and national, to cover various issues within the community. However, Roy emphasized that there is a clear line between legitimate journalism and behaviour intended to provoke, intimidate, or harass.
“This line was crossed,” Roy said. She also pointed out that the harassment of female politicians would not be tolerated, noting the responsibility to provide a safe space for public service.
The incident has raised significant concerns about the safety of politicians, particularly women, in public spaces. Mayor Roy reiterated her commitment to fostering a respectful and constructive environment at Whitby Town Hall and indicated that further steps would be considered to prevent similar occurrences in the future.
The Mayor also expressed confidence in working with town staff and Durham Regional Police to ensure that public meetings remain safe and secure for all attendees. Whitby residents are encouraged to continue their engagement in local politics, with the reassurance that town officials will take measures to protect both public servants and the citizens who attend these meetings.
As of now, Menzies has not responded to requests for comment on the incident.
This event highlights ongoing challenges regarding journalistic conduct and the safety of public officials, particularly in light of increasing tensions in political environments.
